Randy's Pizza is a Durham establishment. A lot of people really love it, but I find it just okay. It's very expensive for what it is, even though the pizza is very large, it's often drippy and floppy and chewy. Sometimes the sauce is really watery and soaks into the crust too much. If you like New York Pizza from New York I recommend going to New York. This pizza does not have that slightly saltine flavor to the crust, nor does it have the correct herbs in the sauce. The cheese doesn't taste quite right either. It's definitely a blend of Romano and other stuff, likely very good cheese. It's just not my thing.
May 29, 2019
Delicious pizza available by the slice and they are big too. They also have one of my favorite meatball subs here. The service is good and the decor passable.
May 16, 2019
Outstanding pizza,....an incredibly delicious combination of tastes. Service was courteous and FAST....and this was on a Friday night. Loved this restaurant.....highly recommended!
Jun 4, 2019
The greatest pizza on the planet. Greasy but not too bad. I love it
Jun 27, 2019
My favorite lunch and takeout pizza in Durham. Their crust is thin, has a nice texture and chewiness, and the sauce is well seasoned. It's not fancy, but it's the best example of NY style pizza around.
At lunch, get the combo - two slices and a soda. The slices are HUGE, warmed up in the oven when you order, and arrives with a browned crust and hot, melty cheese. Just perfect.
Jun 19, 2019
Best big slice of pizza in the area. If you're from DC and miss the Jumbo slice from Adam's Morgan this place will make you feel like home. Just buy the 2 slice special and ask for it to remain uncut. Enjoy!
Aug 3, 2019
Great customer service! Great tasting pizza! You get pizza for your pay! Two slices is all you.need put of a box to fill you up! It was my first time eating here and best believe it won't be my last. I am not from this area but this is the best freshly made pizza I've had in a while! My sister said their pizzas are always good and you get more bang for your buck also! Keep up the great work! In my Terminator voice: "I'll be back!"
Aug 11, 2019
My girlfriend and I were visiting and staying at a hotel close by and I just want to say that the staff was incredibly accommodating but more importantly, that was easily the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. We travel a lot so that says a lot. Please open a Charlotte location!
Oct 19, 2019
I love thin crust pizza so this place was great! Cheap food and quick service.
Sep 5, 2019
Great pizza and phillies! Love their Greek salad. Delivery takes a little longer than dominos and the like, but considering you get real NY pizza instead of grease covered cardboard, totally worth the wait.
Nov 9, 2019
Love this place! Been going here for 11 years, they are always courteous and consistent!
Dec 4, 2019
The best NY style pizza in the triangle. Great calazone as well. Wings good. Greek salad and pizza are worth a try if you like them.
Both Hope Valley Road and University Drive locations are good.
Jan 2, 2020
The pizza slice was huge and very good . Fresh and hot and very tasty and friendly staff !! I recommend Randy's Pizza anytime !!!!
Jan 18, 2020
Good New York style pizza. Large pies with thin, pleasantly chewy crust.
Feb 15, 2020
It's not exactly like New York but I love this pizza
Mar 3, 2020
Their website often sends pickup orders to the wrong location. Call ahead and it's easily 5 stars
Dec 30, 2018
Yum...just yum!! Pizza was excellent! Definitely reminded me of my days In Manhattan.
May 13, 2020
Always great. Employees that are working when I go to pick up my order are always friendly and seem like they care about making good food. Recently I've been getting delivery instead and it's always super fast and as good as ever. Highly recommend the eggplant parm sandwhich with fries.
May 23, 2020
Delicious, greasy, NY style pizza. What more could you want?
Jul 15, 2020
Very quick to get orders ready and out the door. Pizza is really good.