Loading your recommendations…

Randy's Pizza

4.1

1720 Guess Rd
Durham, NC 27701
Phone: (919) 286-7272
Visit Website

Google Reviews

Photo of Jeff Lyons Jeff Lyons
Dec 13, 2023 5

This is the best Randy's, and I've had them all. If the little Italian guy with the toothy whistle and tons of homestyle charisma is still there (I've been doing delivery for awhile but used to go there frequently for a slice), you're golden. Get the knots with your pie and let it be the Kickin' Hawaiian and don't punk out getting anything under the 18 inch. Overall stars on this place should be higher but some of y'all must've caught these heroes on a bad day. Try harder, go back. It's a pizza place. Get pizza.

Photo of BRIAN MASSENGILL BRIAN MASSENGILL
Dec 9, 2023 5

Always a great go-to for lunch. We had their single slices of pizza which were amazing. Beware, the single slices are extra large. Service was fast and friendly and the pizza was piping hot. We will return again when we have a hungering for pizza.

Photo of Eugene Mongello Eugene Mongello
Dec 4, 2023 5

The best fresh made authentic NY style pizza in Durham. Walked in, ordered a large pepperoni on a whim, and were outta there in less than 15 minutes. Outstanding.

Photo of David MacDonald David MacDonald
Nov 7, 2023 4

First time at Randy's. Thin NYC style pizza hit the spot. Blue collar no-nonsense atmosphere. Very good value.

Photo of Brandon Eaves Brandon Eaves
Oct 28, 2023 5

I work in the area, and this is definitely top 5 for me. The best pizza in Durham for sure... at least once a week for me. Stop in and check it out!!

Photo of T T
Oct 26, 2023 5

Love Randy's!! The slices are Ginormous!! And Delicious! Staff was friendly and the seating area was clean. Can't wait to try other items on the menu

Photo of Nancy Parler Nancy Parler
Oct 4, 2023 3

Ordered a Stromboli. Received an all meat Calzone with ZERO CHEESE. Have been going here about 20 years. Last few times very disappointed esp with pizza. Will look for a new Italian place.

Photo of Michael Johnson Michael Johnson
Sep 15, 2023 5

Awesome hole in the wall. Service is outstanding! It's pizza and they had a gluten free option for me :) Healthy isn't a word I'd use to describe them...

Photo of Ty Troy Ty Troy
Aug 11, 2023 5

Great pizza! I love their margherita pizza!

Photo of Natalie Woodland Natalie Woodland
Jul 19, 2023 4

Great food. Prices are a little high, but they do have a rewards program and they send you different promotions. The inside seating is not as clean and welcoming as I’d prefer it, so we usually just get our order to go.

Photo of Dorothy Gentry Dorothy Gentry
Jun 2, 2023 5

Patient. Nice Atmosphere. OUTSIDE TABLE. 3Hr Wait For Rental. Mix up. But I Calmed Down. Hours Of Nice Outdoor Stuff. Watching PEOPLE. Yakking. Phone. Cricket But GOTTA Find Out What To Do BETTER.

Photo of Nyal Cline Nyal Cline
Apr 1, 2023 4

EDIT: The food is generally really good. Service could still use some improvement, but is usually passable. I’ve been going here regularly for 7 years, and never made a fuss if they messed something up ‘cause they always fixed it. Tonight our pizza got crushed. I called to complain, sat on hold over 5 minutes, texted a pic of the mangled food to the “manager”, never got an apology. She would only refund money for pizza, not whole order. I used an online coupon for the pizza, so I said that wouldn’t do. And I had pre-tipped the driver $7. The manager was difficult, unhelpful, unsympathetic and uncompromising. I’ll go to Italian Pizzaria on Roxboro from now on. All over a $26 order. Service has gone way down hill.