Loading your recommendations…

Randy's Pizza

4.1

1720 Guess Rd
Durham, NC 27701
Phone: (919) 286-7272
Visit Website

Google Reviews

Photo of Darlene Bacon Darlene Bacon
Jul 7, 2019 5

I absolutely love this place, pizza is awesome and I LOVE the salads. Good prices.

Photo of John Mathis John Mathis
Jun 20, 2019 4

The only Randy's that doesn't serve beer. But the staff is quick, friendly and thoughtful. Small space that gets loud quick.,

Photo of Brenda Frances Brenda Frances
Jun 9, 2019 4

Great place for a small party thank you for helping very professional staff

Photo of Cathy Randazzo Cathy Randazzo
Apr 9, 2019 5

In town from STL my uncle suggested Randy's. Excellent beef and cheese sandwich. Wings and thin crust pizza we brought home for dinner. Outstanding!!! See you next trip.thanks again

Photo of gina paris gina paris
May 12, 2019 5

Awesome service. Friendly . i had pasta with pesto and garlic bread. Had some of my boyfriends fries. Delicious 😋

Photo of Kevin Self Kevin Self
Mar 15, 2019 3

The 14" pizza was great. Crust was just right to bite into. Good amount of cheese & sauce. Just enough pepperonis for a 1/2 & 1/2 pizza. Restaurant is clean and staff was nice.

Photo of Megan Young Megan Young
Apr 2, 2022 3

The food is kind of a hit or miss. The sandwiches and wings and pizzas are great, but some of the pasta leaves a little to be desired. Randy's stromboli and the steak and cheese sub are my favorite recommendations.

Photo of Shar Rosa Shar Rosa
Nov 13, 2021 5

NY / NJ FOLKS: EAT HERE!!! We are unusually opinionated Yankees who love excellent pizza and this is our place. The pizza is large, hot, and delicious. They have REAL WHITE pizza, too!! But above all...the tangy BBQ wings are spot the eff on! Omg!! Make sure to order from them directly. Their rewards program is insane. We love Randy's and you will too.

Photo of Scott Johnson Scott Johnson
Jan 24, 2022 5

Pizza was great! Plenty of toppings and a great crust! Team was friendly and nice. Only demerit was that most the toppings had shifted to one side of the pie but it was still edible and delicious!

Photo of zack702 zack702
Aug 6, 2021 4

Yummy pizza New York style big slices. My opinion is there pizza and pasta are better than most of the competition.

Photo of Frank Sirico Jr Frank Sirico Jr
Mar 31, 2022 4

Not going to lie, I went in here blind and not knowing what to expect. Overall I was happy with my decision. The slices were larger than expected and a great price of $3.30 per, dough was firm but foldable, sauce was average and the cheese was normal. 4 out of 5 stars and I will come back.

Photo of Bridget Fasion Bridget Fasion
Jan 20, 2021 3

Where is Tony? Stop serving ppl steak that has been sitting its definitely not like it used to be

Photo of Zach Leonard Zach Leonard
Dec 12, 2020 5

Solid New York pizza and good sandwiches and salads, always reliable and delivery is quick

Photo of Ken Smith Ken Smith
Dec 6, 2020 3

Good solid New York pizza. Not the best pizza in town but very good.

Photo of Cristin Parrish Cristin Parrish
Nov 11, 2020 5

Best New York Style Pizza in Durham! Excellent menu items and deals. LOVE Randy’s Pizza since 1999!

Photo of Matthew Cloues Matthew Cloues
Sep 19, 2020 5

I have been eating at Randy’s starting with the first location many years ago. This was always a good location, but today I think it is the best one minus the fact it could use a facelift on the inside. Great pizza. Wings are very food. Friendly staff. The pizza though is great and consistent. I have made this my preferred of the Randy’s location because it is so consistent.

Photo of Drew Betz Drew Betz
Aug 7, 2020 3

COVID-19 Safety Assessment: Visited 8/7/2020 — Two cooks preparing pizzas did not have masks on. Two additional workers did not have gloves on. Customers waiting were unable to effectively distance inside. I will not be returning during this pandemic until better, common sense, protocols are put in place and enforced my management.

Photo of Dan Kujo Dan Kujo
Aug 29, 2020 5

Go to Pizza place for regular New York style pie. Also I enjoy the dinners like manicotti and baked ziti. Garlic knots are great too.

Photo of Drew Betz Drew Betz
Aug 7, 2020 3

COVID-19 Safety Assessment: Visited 8/7/2020 — Two cooks preparing pizzas did not have masks on. Two additional workers did not have gloves on. Customers waiting were unable to effectively distance inside. I will not be returning during this pandemic until better, common sense, protocols are put in place and enforced my management.

Photo of William Bailey William Bailey
Aug 3, 2020 4

A good, consistent pizza. Good crust. Not "the best", but good.

Photo of Batnr Batnr
Jun 24, 2020 5

OH MY GOD! You have to eat at this place. The pizza is so good, and I recommend the garlic knots as a side dish. My family and I eat here every Friday.

Photo of Sue C Sue C
May 18, 2020 5

We got the menu from a flyer in the hotel we are staying at. BEST decision of the day! The ziti is amazing. But that garlic bread??? Oh my goodness!! Came with a nice size salad too. Hubby said the spaghetti was good too. Glad I brought a small cooler with us because a lot is going home!

Photo of Matthew Cloues Matthew Cloues
Nov 19, 2018 3

So I generally am very happy with the food at this location and sometimes think it serves the best pizza of any of the Randy's locations. The slices are huge even by Randy's standards. I mark it down to 3 stars for three reasons. First it is inconsistent, mostly very good, but occasionally not close to as good as usual. Two, I am not asking for much given it is a pizza shop, but it needs a bit if a facelift or something. It feels dreary. Third, staff just isn't very welcoming. I dont like the parking lot either. Why do I still go here? It is fantastic pizza on most days.

Photo of Karen Aleman Diaz Karen Aleman Diaz
May 6, 2020 5

Absolutely love Randy's pizza. Great food and great staff. Always a great experience!

Photo of Fortuitous Capture Fortuitous Capture Fortuitous Capture Fortuitous Capture
May 30, 2018 5

Always the best pizza in town.

Photo of Mischia Parks Mischia Parks
Jan 2, 2020 5

The Food was absolutely delicious you can not ask for better PIZZA The staff is wonderful and PIZZA and SANDWICHES are off the charts !!! I would eat here any time !!!!

Photo of Russell Burnett Russell Burnett
Dec 14, 2019 4

They are one of the very best pizza joints in town. Good service and prices and in addition to great pizza they make terrific hot/cold subs, pasta dishes, and wings.

Photo of Tarshia Edwards Tarshia Edwards
Sep 15, 2019 5

My first time here was awesome. It had an ole skool city vibe. Very authentic pizza place.

Photo of Joni S Joni S
Oct 17, 2019 5

This wasn't initially our first choice for pizza, but I'm very very glad that we ended up eating here. Their margherita pizza was the best I've had. We also ordered the Greek pizza (with feta, red onions and kalamata olives). Out of this world. The interior isn't fancy at all, which is a plus in my book. Delicious pizza and I can feel comfortable wearing whatever? Score.

Photo of Brandon Fisher Brandon Fisher
Jul 15, 2019 5

I’ve been going to Randy’s Pizza for over 15 years, always have a pleasant experience. Can’t remember a single time I was not happy with the food or service......in 15 years !!!! Family friendly and my favorite place to get a Philly cheesesteak, nuff said. Go there, eat there, leave happy.

Photo of thomas dooris thomas dooris
Aug 4, 2019 5

Best little pizza spot in all of Durham. Greasy delicious real NY style. They do something right because the pizza is superior to most others in area.

Photo of Gloria Teasley Gloria Teasley
May 3, 2022 4

We love Randy's pizzas. Lately when we go for pizza we all order subs. Great pasta also. I really like eating there with family and friends. Very casual atmosphere. Staff are quick to eat food out. Like every other business, they have had to increase their prices. But they are still reasonable.

Photo of William Torian William Torian
Apr 28, 2022 4

One of my favorite places to go to get pizza, wings, salads, subs. Always fresh, pizza has a good amount of toppings on it. If you are a pizza fan, check out Randy's. You won't be disappointed

Photo of Henry Peterman Henry Peterman
May 27, 2022 4

Best NY city style slices I have found in North Carolina. This is my pizza spot when I'm in Durham. - Long Island born and raised.