If you're looking for no-frills, New York-style pizza delivery classic toppings, Randy's is your spot. Feed a crowd with a 30" pie, and practice your New York fold with a giant slice for yourself. Count on consistently delicious pizza as Randy's has been operating in the Triangle for over 25 years.
Share
Hours:
Monday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM Tuesday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM Wednesday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM Thursday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM Friday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM Saturday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM Sunday: 12:00 – 9:00 PM
Basic pizza place, very thrifty about toppings, though. A very sad 18-inch pizza had about two pepperoni per slice (8 slices). I would rather go anywhere else.
Paulina Bahary
Jan 22, 2025
5
Best pizza in Durham!!!!! And BEST NY pizza. I lived in NY for almost 30 years and Randy’s is as good as any top notch NY pizza shop. Amazing food and amazing people and service. Look forward to dining there again!
Juan DiGiulio
Nov 26, 2024
4
The pizza is one of the best in Durham. If you have spent time in Durham, you know what that means. The Calzones are pretty good as well. They are not really charitable with their toppings so it’s hard to afford any extras. I tried the lasagna tonight. One word. Turdsagna. I just invented that word bc that’s what it is. Truly. Big globs of sugary meat sauce with 2-3 pieces of lasagna noodles, covered in copious amounts of cheese. Definitely no ricotta. Definitely no love to be found in the preparation of the turdsagna. Stouffer’s puts it to shame. 🤮
Arthur Zak
Nov 5, 2024
5
Native New Yorker here. This is abkut your average NYC corner slice shop pizza, which makes it 5 stars here in NC. Very enjoyable crust and flavor, hits the spot.
Sarah Bolen
Oct 24, 2024
3
Love their pizza, like the speed of their delivery. But they always manage to forget at least one topping. It’s uncanny. Order pepperoni, spinach & feta, and you’ll get pepperoni & spinach. And spend an extra $5 on the nonexistent feta.
Shirley Williams
Jun 17, 2024
4
I ordered a steak and cheese with onion rings. The steak and cheese was amazing. The onion rings were horrible. They were not fresh. I believe they were refried. I have had their fresh onion rings in the past and they are really good. I was really disappointed.
Jacob Perry
Jun 14, 2024
3
Pizza by the slice is big. However, the three stars is for the price. Two slices are $8.60. A large dominos pizza is $8.63. I love Randy's New York slice (as does my New Yorker wife), but not their non-New York price.
