Loading your recommendations…

Randy's Pizza

4

1813 Martin Luther King Jr Pkwy
Durham, NC 27707
Phone: (919) 490-6850
Visit Website

Google Reviews

Photo of Douglas Stalters Douglas Stalters
May 31, 2019 5

Consistently good. Been going there for 8 years and it's always the same. Excellent!

Photo of NeamaDoesGames NeamaDoesGames
Jun 10, 2019 5

The food was delicious and the pizza was really nice and cheesy, overall nice place.

Photo of Ayana Ayana
May 28, 2019 5

I’m down to one Gryo a week, formerly 2-3 was the norm for me. The Gryos as awesome, very filling and seasoned perfectly. I can’t attest for the sub options, oddly enough I’ve never tried the subs. Pizza is good, slices are massive 😃.

Photo of Carylon Hamlett Carylon Hamlett
Mar 21, 2019 3

This was my first visit to Randy's. I'm from Greensboro and my sweetheart said the pizza was really good. I'm a pizza lover and can eat pizza every day. I gave Randy's three stars because it lacked toppings and I told the young lady we were dining in. We waited 20 minutes for our pizza,a meat lovers,and when I went to check on our order it was sitting on top of the oven in a box. The flavor was good but the amount or lack there of was dismal to say the least.

Photo of Dawn DaSilva Dawn DaSilva
Mar 2, 2019 5

The company I work for recently ordered Randy's Pizza for lunch, and I was pleasantly surprised at how good their pizza was. Definitely the closest to New York Style I have ever had in North Carolina. I highly recommend this place to family and friends and plan to visit in the future! Great job! Perfect location!

Photo of Nancy Cabrera Nancy Cabrera
Mar 4, 2022 5

BEST PIZZA hands down! Many people claim to be NY pizza but Randy’s is the BEST pizza and it’s literally NY pizza. Took me a while to find this place but I’m obsess , pie didn’t stand a chance. 100000/10

Photo of Bryan Christenson-Diver Bryan Christenson-Diver
Feb 23, 2022 5

Randy's is AWESOME. It was in Durham way before Durham was "cool" or "trendy" and is my first and only choice for some good pizza in the city. I love it and have converted many friends after just one visit :) I haven't had their non-pizza menu items, but once you have their pizza there will be no going back!

Photo of Anne Kyle Anne Kyle
Dec 12, 2020 5

Just had the most delicious pizza! My parents have lived in the area for decades but have never really noticed Randy’s, even though they shop next door all the time. We ordered a Greek pizza which was absolutely delicious. Best New York pizza I’ve had outside New York. Lovely staff, delicious pizza, great offers - what’s not to love?

Photo of Demi Nicholas Demi Nicholas
Dec 2, 2020 5

The original location of Randy’s Pizza has great subs and huge slices of pizza! You have to fold them to eat—just like in New York! I really enjoy the Greek Pizza and Italian Subs at this location! Fast service, friendly people. Treat me as family when I come in!

Photo of Chen Zhu Chen Zhu
Nov 4, 2020 5

Been coming here for about 10 years. Quality is always good. I just ordered the poboy for the first time - it was great.

Photo of Heather P. McPherson Heather P. McPherson
Apr 20, 2018 5

Great NY style pizza, hot and cold subs, pasta as well as other Italian cuisine, being calzones, my favorite ham and cheese. Salads and garlic knots round out menu. Their NY cheesecake with or without real strawberry topping is SOO good, without question some of best in Durham. Voted Best of the Traingle by the Indy in 14, 15 and 2016! Small but cozy dining room is always bustling with a crowd, including a small outdoor dining area. Fast, friendly service makes Randys one of our favorite, pick up or delivery, pizza joints in town!!! Free parking and wheel chair accessible as well as restrooms. Check in with Yelp for specials!

Photo of Tom Baumann Tom Baumann
Jun 23, 2020 4

Very good New York style pizza! 😋

Photo of Matthew Cloues Matthew Cloues
Sep 10, 2019 5

I am revising my rating to 5 stars. I had rated lower as I felt like quality had declined as well as consistency over the years, but they really have stepped it back up. This is amazing NY style pizza and my favorite in Durham. They have sandwiches and pasta, but pizza is where it is at. I always think their (massive) slices are the best value, but you really can't go wrong either way.

Photo of J P J P
Feb 25, 2020 5

Miss the Jumbo slice in DC? No worries! Ask for the 2 slice deal and tell them to keep them uncut. You'll be back @Adam's Morgan without the people watching lol. Pizza is the best!

Photo of Mischia Parks Mischia Parks
Jan 2, 2020 5

Garlic Knots are off the chart and the CHEF Salad was so yummy and fresh . I will come here again and the staff was Fantastic and friendly.

Photo of Marta Avery Marta Avery
Dec 30, 2019 4

Nice food but it was cold in side.

Photo of Lloyd Moore Lloyd Moore
Dec 28, 2019 4

Great NY style pizza, at a great price. The locational proximity of both resturants to movie theatres, makes this a wonderful affordable pre (or post) movie meal option.

Photo of Jesse Merritt Jesse Merritt
Dec 11, 2019 5

The food is good and the best service check it out

Photo of Michael Green Michael Green
Nov 26, 2019 5

Legit New York style pizza! This I know because I was raised in New York.

Photo of Teylo Thornton Teylo Thornton
Nov 21, 2019 4

Service is usually good and friendly. But this place's hot Italian sub has spoiled me for anywhere else! :-(

Photo of James Foster James Foster
Oct 25, 2019 5

Best NYC style pizza in N Carolina

Photo of Kristen Spitzer Kristen Spitzer
Oct 24, 2019 4

Great pizza. I grew up in NY and it’s the closest to real NY pizza that I can find in Durham. Only reason I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 is that their service can be hit or miss. Sometimes they’re great, no problems. Other times they act as if the couldn’t care less about you. It won’t stop me from ordering from there but I’d rather not be hung up on, you know.

Photo of Kimberly Carmon Kimberly Carmon
Sep 15, 2019 5

Best New York Style Pozza in this area! Please open a Randy's Pizza in Mebane near Tanger Outlets!

Photo of Norbert Mildner Norbert Mildner
Oct 5, 2019 5

just pizza but nice and tasty. call ahead they are quite busy

Photo of Aimee Aimee Aimee Aimee
Oct 4, 2019 3

It's okey for me..i might need to come back and order a different item on the menu to convince myself that it is great

Photo of Joe Olejar Joe Olejar
Jul 23, 2019 4

Well, we stopped at Randy's while on errands. I went in and asked for two slices of sausage pizza. When my name was called, they handed me a 12" box. Opening the box revealed the two slices filling the whole thing! Talk about value!

Photo of Liza MacDonald Liza MacDonald
Jul 10, 2019 5

Best NY pizza around. Thin crust, large slices, delicious flavor. Couldn’t stop myself from getting a slice regularly.

Photo of D B D B
Aug 16, 2019 5

There are no words to describe how delicious this pizza is. I like my pizza unadulterated... Just a plain cheese slice and they do it right. I cannot wait to go back!

Photo of John John
Jun 7, 2022 4

Take it from a life long New Yorker: this is the closest thing to NY style pizza you will find in a 15 mile radius. Good stuff.

Photo of Barbara L Barbara L
Mar 14, 2021 5

Consistently fantastic. There are times when my cravings for the kind of pizza I used to get in northern NJ are irresistible, and this Randy's location always does the trick.

Photo of Sara Jane Danaher Sara Jane Danaher
Aug 9, 2022 5

Best Greek Salad around, and the pizza is amazing too. It’s most like pizza from Brooklyn, NY I ordered a meatball sandwich recently that was so good I can still recall it’s yummy taste.

Photo of Evangelist Ervin Wilson Evangelist Ervin Wilson
Aug 30, 2022 3

This particular time my two slices were the smallest I've ever had; makes me wonder. Otherwise Randy's is still my favorite place to get pizza. I hope that the slices return to there normal size.

Photo of Carlos Nyc Carlos Nyc
May 22, 2022 4

The pizza is always great...but today we decided to dine.The tables really needed to to wiped off...

Photo of A Lewis A Lewis
Mar 24, 2022 3

Pizza was good but the fries taste as if they were cooked in old grease and refried. Very disappointment