I never write reviews but this pizza was so delicious! And so cheap. Service was fast and friendly as well. I will definitely be back!
Selena Rodriguez
Apr 8, 2025
5
The pizza is absolutely delicious, I highly recommend the personal pizza with a drink.
Lisa Quinn
Feb 11, 2025
5
I was so surprised to see that they had ice cream and I can't wait to go back for a cone! The place was bigger inside than expected and I thought the atmosphere was fun with a tv and fun art on the wall. The staff was very friendly and I really love this meat ball sub I brought home with me! The meatballs are amazing!
Juan Andres
Dec 14, 2024
5
After a long day at a soccer tournament, we called in an order for two large pizzas, and they were ready in less than 20 minutes! The service was quick, and the pizzas were absolutely delicious.
Perfect for a post-game meal—great food and super convenient. Highly recommend!
Jackson Howe
Oct 18, 2024
3
The food was mediocre at best, the meatballs had zero flavor and they forgot about half of our order and it took extra time to get our complete order
Christopher Schultz
Oct 3, 2024
4
One of the few places in the Triangle where you can get pizza by the slice. This is very close to standard New York style that you can get in Manhattan, and its quality is pretty close to the real deal with chewy crust with the crisp “undercarriage” that is synonymous with a NY style pizza.
jess 1969
Sep 23, 2024
5
Excellent food and customer service! 🎈
Fist time to dine here today and I must say that the pizza here is comparable to NYC pizza❤️ The owner/server are kind, friendly and accommodating, always checking if everything is ok. I would definitely come back here for dine in and pickup. I was surprised to see the dining area is spacious and cozy and the pizza is not your mainstream cardboard pizza. Truly a gem in this area. Thank you and I love NY pizza!
Henry Watkins Jr
Aug 13, 2024
5
1st time ordering, Better than fast food. 1/2 lb burger and fries large order, had to take home. Wife got the Sliced chicken Stromboli and dessert. 2 people could have eaten that stuffed Stromboli. Great service. Definitely will be back.
A. Rousseau
Aug 11, 2024
4
* Pizza Quality: The pizzas at “I Love NY Pizza” are good, with a nice balance of cheese, sauce, and toppings.
* Variety: They offer a wide variety of toppings to choose from, catering to different tastes and preferences.
* Service: The staff is friendly and efficient, providing quick service to customers.
* Ambiance: The restaurant has a cozy and welcoming ambiance, making it a great place to enjoy a meal with friends or family.
Click on the helpful button if you found this review helpful.
#ARousseauPic #Restaurant #ARTravel #ARFoodReview #Pizza #ILoveNYPizza #DurhamNC #NorthCarolina
Cee Mason
Aug 4, 2024
5
It's hard to do pizza wrong but it's even harder to do pizza as right as this place. I'm a "by the slice" customer and any time they don't have my favorite, they will make it for me. My loyalty is difficult to earn, but I've been going to this store for at least 10 years and since I moved closer, I go almost every Saturday! I love NY Pizza is an absolute "go to" location for consistent quality and service from Wilmington to Durham to Chapel Hill. If you want satisfaction, come join us here!
Christine Jones
Jul 21, 2024
5
Being from the Northeast originally until 19 years ago, my Mom and I have to say that it's some of the best pizza in North Carolina! I worked in this shopping mall until almost 10 years ago and had been here several times. Within the past couple years off and on, I've been getting pizza here again and my Mom works right up the road and thinks she'll be getting pizza here on her way home from work. My best friend and I have been here before, but came again last night and our server "Ali" was so kind and cordial to all of us this weekend and gave great service. I hope he's our server in the future.
Em C
Jul 19, 2024
5
Delicious pizza. We love the dine in area because of New York vibes. Happy eating🥰
