Loading your recommendations…

I Love NY Pizza

4.2

5428 New Hope Commons Blvd Ext
Durham, NC 27707
Phone: (919) 401-4224
Visit Website

Google Reviews

Photo of Ahmad Zamzam Ahmad Zamzam
Aug 11, 2022 5

My family and I really love this place. They are very professional and welcoming with a top-notch service! Their food is super delicious!

Photo of Jenny Sechrist Jenny Sechrist
Aug 8, 2022 5

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐My kids and I love this pizza! It is the absolute best. The ice cream is great as well. The owners and employees are amazing and the atmosphere is so chill!

Photo of Ganesh Venkataraman Ganesh Venkataraman
Aug 2, 2022 5

Incredible pizza place!!! A small Mom and Pop store in Durham,NC that offers fresh, tasty and super cost effective pizza combos! 2 big slices of pizza with a side/drink for $9 in today’s world is just WOW!

Photo of ninja syn ninja syn
Jul 17, 2022 3

I think the Philly Steak and cheese is one of the best I ever had, until I asked for a side of banana peppers and the young man with the blonde hair with the tapered sides and the earing in his ear, used his bare hands to grab the banana peppers and put them into the container. I quickly made him aware I DEFINITELY DO NOT WANT THOSE!! I requested he please put gloves or better yet use a pair of tongs to get them out. This made me VERY CAUTIOUS TO EAT ANYTHING FROM HERE AGAIN!!

Photo of Verdale Green Verdale Green
Jun 27, 2022 5

This restaurant does not deserve any stars they deserve an Oscar the way they are serving hot food out of the establishment not only all the food top-tier but it is worth over five stars I would highly recommend anyone to stop by I love New York pizza if you’re in the Durham area is Definitely worth your time and money

Photo of Ganesh Venkataraman Ganesh Venkataraman
Jun 21, 2022 5

Mom and pop pizza shop that is incredible!! We frequent this place!! Great combos with good pricing! - made fresh. Easily the best place in the Raleigh/Durham area!

Photo of Tina Wilkins Tina Wilkins
May 27, 2022 5

This place rocks. Food is varied and amazing. Tons of choices. Wish it were closer. We will definitely be back!

Photo of Arnice Cooke Arnice Cooke
Apr 1, 2022 5

Nice staff and great food! They always prepare my order correctly.. No cheese No. Mayo. Thanks for listening to your customers!

Photo of Vikki Posada Vikki Posada
Mar 23, 2022 5

The atmosphere here is comfortable and the staff is friendly and welcoming. We ordered a NY style pizza, wings and garlic knots and everything was delicious! We will definitely be back next week! Update: came back and dined in, my entire family was so happy with all of our food and are looking forward to coming back yet again for dinner!

Photo of bmas44 bmas44
Feb 21, 2022 5

A surprisingly really good pizza place. And all the other food they have is good too. Normally any kind of pasta dish or wings from a pizza place are terrible, but honestly their other dishes are really good. I had the vegetarian lasagna it is honestly one of the better vegetarian lasagnas I've ever had. The wings are great too. Really happy with the food.

Photo of philly bronx philly bronx
Jan 9, 2022 5

This was our first time here and the place smells great,reminds me of being back home .Customer service was awesome,We ordered some pizza and wings which are really good and desert. Definitely coming back

Photo of Nicholas Ojeda Nicholas Ojeda
Jan 8, 2022 5

This is my favorite pizza shop! The owner and staff here are awesome. Everyone has a great vibe and they really cares about there guests. The food is amazing and there are plenty of options to choose from. If you decide to dine in the restaurant has a great atmosphere and design. Also they keep it very clean. I am always very impressed with everything when I arrive. I highly recommend you try one of their desserts. Finally, to locate them, they are located in between Burlington and cricket wireless

Photo of H xD H xD
Dec 17, 2021 5

Got the steak stromboli and it was delicious.it was really well made, had plenty of ingredients, and it wasn't greasy. The dipping sauce was delicious it was flavorful and not just watered down marinara sauce, it was actually seasoned. I can't wait to visit again to try other items on the menu. My father is not a big pizza fan but he was impressed and can't wait to visit again.

Photo of Austin King Austin King
Dec 12, 2021 5

I Love NY Pizza is great. My wife and I stopped by after landing in Raleigh. We had a three hour drive home and needed some food. If you see any low reviews, ignore them. Don’t miss out. These are great people AND they serve great pizza! 🗽🍕