Loading your recommendations…

I Love NY Pizza

4.2

5428 New Hope Commons Blvd Ext
Durham, NC 27707
Phone: (919) 401-4224
Visit Website

I Love NY Pizza

Google Reviews

Photo of mimicat333 mimicat333
May 6, 2019 4

We tried their meat lover pizza (ham, bacon and pepperoni) but barely tasted and found any bacon.....and the dough was not to our taste either, kinda soggy and not thin enough.....got to say we were pretty disappointed with the pizza there. However, we LOVE their pastry!!! Best tiramisu and baklava!!!! Tried their tuxedo cake and it was great too!! Staff are friendly. Will be back for more dessert!! Maybe we'll try different kind of pizza...

Photo of Matthew Cowles Matthew Cowles
Jun 15, 2019 4

To start with, the pizza was fine. Variety: Decent. About 10-15 varieties of pizza toppings on slices, ready to be reheated and served. Also two stuffed pizza slice varieties and threw stromboli varieties. (More could be ordered/made, but would have taken longer). Taste: It was fine, bordering on good. I tried a stuffed meat lovers slice and had no regrets. A big larger of a marinara sauce would've been nice, but maybe I just like more sauce than normal. Speed and other things: Friendly staff. Ordered fast. Served fast. Place felt clean (worker was actually washing the windows, when I arrived). Price: It felt a bit more expensive than it should've been. I ordered a combo of a stuffed slice of pizza and a drink, for $9.99. I realized after the fact that just a stuffed slice of pizza was $7.99. So the "combo" price added a medium fountain drink for two dollars. I looked more at the menu and there were other oddities like that. So just be careful. Overall: It wasn't bad. If I'm near one and really craving a slice, I wouldn't say no. But I wouldn't ever be sitting at home, wanting a slice, and seek it out.

Photo of Pamela Torain Pamela Torain
May 20, 2019 5

Slices as big as your head! Takes me back to Brooklyn. No pork ingredients... real beef pepperoni. So good.

Photo of Stephanie Hartness Stephanie Hartness
May 11, 2019 5

Best pizza ever!!! Great customer service! Never expected such a warm welcome and generosity! Will be back!

Photo of Pamela Sherrill Pamela Sherrill
Jun 1, 2019 5

If you enjoy great food and great service, give I Love NY Pizza, my first time going 6/1/19 with my sweet heart, but we will be going back with my poohda/grandson

Photo of Pierre Estrella Pierre Estrella
Jul 20, 2019 5

As soon as I walked up to the store front, I started to get that N.Y. feeling! Walked in, took a whiff and got that comfort feeling of a pizzeria in N.Y. I was in there with my family and they made us feel like family! I mentioned how good the veggie Stromboli looked, immediately the guy told me that I would love it, so I got excited and took his his advice and he was telling the truth! It was delicious! Now it's one of my favorites! After all was said and done they gave us a Sunday to feed the family. I highly recommend this place!

Photo of Jeffrey White Jeffrey White
Aug 16, 2019 5

This place is a buried treasure back in the shopping center. Pizza slices were hot, melty, huge, and delicious. The service of these guys was impeccable. They saw we were on a date and even let me pay after eating and brought a complimentary sundae to our table. It was a wonderful experience. We will definitely be back... and soon. :)

Photo of Katelyn G Katelyn G
Jul 18, 2019 4

Friendly service, and pretty fast too. The only reason I didn't give 5 stars is because the prices tend to get kind of high, especially on the cake slices and ice cream but other than that, I have no complaints.

Photo of Irv Litt Irv Litt
Jul 22, 2019 4

Pretty good pizza.. they cooked it the way that I like it. (Crunchy!) Lol nice staff as well

Photo of Plumpeez Deli Plumpeez Deli
Oct 19, 2019 5

From the owners of a New York style deli to the owners and food of a New York style pizzeria THANK YOU! Thank you for making me feel like I’m in Brooklyn every single time that I come in. The lamb gyros and beef patties with cheese are absolutely delicious!!!! Thank you for your wonderful service. Thank you for being around. Can’t wait to return!

Photo of Bill Reed Bill Reed
Oct 19, 2019 4

Food good. Pizza looked thin and cook right. We had dinners. Had to order in one place. Food served all at once: salad and dinner. Missing salad dressing. Then go up and tell man what we had for dinner and pay. Dishonest could easily just walk out. Food medium hot. Get iwnplastic knifes and forks, self serve soda.

Photo of Caleb Neff Caleb Neff
Sep 3, 2019 5

I love this PIZZA place!... this is just like the pizza in NYC... they have great prices and a nice staff... have never had anything less than the best from here!