Skip to content
64°F





Loading your recommendations…

,

I Love NY Pizza

4.2

5428 New Hope Commons Blvd Ext
Durham, NC 27707
Phone: (919) 401-4224
Visit Website

Hours:

Monday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM
Saturday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM
Sunday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM

Price Range
Visit Website

See something wrong with this listing? Contact blog@discoverdurham.com.

I Love NY Pizza
Mapped location of I Love NY Pizza

Google Reviews

4.2
Write A Review

See All

Photo of Erick von Schulz Erick von Schulz
Mar 4, 2026 5

I love this place. Pizza is true NY style. They always know my order when I walk in. Great staff amazing pizza. You will not regret trying it.

Photo of Dontray Cole Dontray Cole
Mar 2, 2026 5

Hey I really appreciate you guys for the great service and the great food it was soo good I can’t wait to come back again that Philly cheese steak sandwich was great 8/10 I enjoyed it and the fry’s were great as well thanks guys and you guys served food before 12pm that’s. Great

Photo of Elizabeth Aycock Elizabeth Aycock
Feb 16, 2026 5

Very delicious! I love their subs, especially the meatball and Philly cheese steak. The sub bread is soft, the produce always fresh and the fries are perfectly cooked!12/10

Photo of Ken Graves Ken Graves
Feb 8, 2026 5

The staff and owner are still amazing food still amazing. Now with great milkshakes and a new setup and prices are still great as well.

Photo of Toussaint Toole Toussaint Toole
Feb 3, 2026 3

What is the point in teasing your customers? I love NY pizza too, but sure didn't find it here. The person at the counter didn't even know what zeppolis are. SMH. These restaurants just need to say pizza, not NY pizza. It feels like a scam, and I won't go back. The place that I found the closest to NY pizza doesn't even have NY in its name. I eat there all the time, and they have zeppolis. I'm born and raised in NY, transplanted to NC 3 years ago, like a lot of New Yorkers. You can't fool us

Photo of Eva Eva Eva Eva
Jan 31, 2026 5

Food so good! Best garlic bread in the world! Smell so good taste so good!! Recommended. Pizza lasagna wings all good

Photo of Neil Kage (NN24) Neil Kage (NN24)
Dec 21, 2025 5

My nephew and I got a simple slice of xl cheese and sicilian pizza. The xl's sauce to cheese ratio 10/10 plus it being warm it still was very crispy. If we had got a whole pizza I can imagine how much better it would've been. The same goes for the Sicilian but crispy, flaky golden bottom with a soft and fluffy chew. They know what they're doing here.

Photo of Gladis Villatoro Gladis Villatoro
Nov 22, 2025 5

My favorite place to eat pizza I love NEW YORK pizza ❤️👌

Photo of Cortez Urquheart Cortez Urquheart
Aug 24, 2025 5

Today was my first time coming here & I had a good experience, the pizza was fresh & hot . Great taste . I had BBQ chicken slice & cheese. Everything was perfect

Photo of EDWARD EDWARD
Jul 7, 2025 5

I had the spaghetti with meat sauce. The serving was very large and tasty. It came with a small but fresh and delicious salad and two excellent garlic butter rolls. I would have preferred stainless utensils instead of plastic, but they worked.

Photo of Ehab Aleksan Ehab Aleksan
Jun 14, 2025 5

Immediately when I walked in, I was greeted with such enthusiasm and kindness. They were very patient with me as I decided what I wanted . The customer service and professionalism were amazing, and the food was even better !!!!!! Will definitely be coming back at least once a week.

Photo of Julie Marie Aleksan Julie Marie Aleksan
Jun 14, 2025 5

The food was delicious. I had the gyro and pizza and they were both great. The service was very nice and fast. Will definitely come again.

Photo of NSA NSA
Jun 3, 2025 3

Walked in for a cheese slice Paid 4.50 something post tax Slice is large But the taste wasn't there for me.

Photo of madi madi madi madi madi madi
Apr 13, 2025 5

I never write reviews but this pizza was so delicious! And so cheap. Service was fast and friendly as well. I will definitely be back!

Photo of Selena Rodriguez Selena Rodriguez
Apr 8, 2025 5

The pizza is absolutely delicious, I highly recommend the personal pizza with a drink.