Amazing as always. Very popular for good reason. Grandma style pizza is the best. Cool atmosphere, right down town. I want to tell people to go, but then it will mean the place will always be packed and it will be harder for me to order there. So out pure self interest, don't go here because you will love it and keep coming back, thus making lines longer.
Jun 8, 2019
Very nice casual spot for pizza and beer. The pizza is pricey, but really good with creative toppings. It's a nice place to just hang and drink after eating too. We had a decent sized group and there was plenty of seating, but it can get competitive for larger groups because it's first come, first serve seating with counter service. I love the counter service option though.
May 25, 2019
This is not a brick oven and if you like your pizza burnt, this is not the place for you. However, this is the best pizza I have tasted in Durham. The crust is perfect. The spicy vodka pizza was delicious.
Apr 14, 2019
Really cool place. Not big but has outside and inside searing. Some good microbrews on tap and very tasty pizza and apps. We had a happy hour there and the service was great.
Mar 31, 2019
New Best pizza place in downtown Durham. All of the pizzas are extremely flavorful and the 2 types of crusts are both delicious and done right. It is so refreshing to eat in a pizza place that doesn't think burning the crust in a wood fire oven is either interesting or flavorful.
Jul 2, 2019
Hutchins Garage is my happy place. Every time I go I know 2 things: 1) I'm gonna order a Grandma style pizza and it will be amazing and 2) they'll have a fantastic, hazy IPA on tap to compliment my meal. I've eaten a lot of pizza in the Triangle, and this is definitely my favorite. I rarely have room, but their tiramisu is also top-notch. Service is great, bartenders are friendly and quick, and the outdoor seating is nice. There's a reason Indy Weekly named it best new restaurant of 2019.
Jun 25, 2019
Stopped by to honor their time in giving me directions to an event. They went out of their way to help. Came back and really liked the Burial Skillet Donut Stout. The pizza was wonderful and the service was perfect, very helpful, but not hovering. I will return.
Sep 7, 2019
I'd heard the pizza was good so it was time to partake and see if the hype was matched.
Cons, menu was odd, ordering was more take out than anything, staff was...... Minimally helpful. Parking is non existent.
Pros, pizza was freaking awesome. Cooked right to that perfect, crisp point without being burnt and the ingredients tasted fresh. Place was clean, bathroom was clean. (Men's, I don't buy into the gender hype, I use the men's room) Atmosphere was cool and I really like that old building.
End result, I'll be back. Here's to hoping that like a lot of places they don't start backsliding.
Sep 3, 2019
Seems like Durham doesn't need another pizza place, and yet here it is. And it's good. Nice bar with a variety of taps, friendly service. Outdoor seating is a big plus. Set back far enough from the street you don't feel like you're sitting on the sidewalk. Inside is comfortable as well.
Aug 4, 2019
I enjoyed the atmosphere. This restaurant is situated in an old garage and has a lot of personality. You can eat outside of inside and enjoy the uniqueness of it all. The food was good and the staff were knowledgeable. Definitely a spot to hit after drinking beer in the vicinity
Aug 25, 2019
Funky atmosphere, delicious pizza, great beer list. The pizza really stands out though. Both the thin and thicker crust are delicious compliments to the wide array of toppings. Nice chew to the base, crispiness on the edge. The specialty pies we've tried have been fantastic
Three restaurant is in an old service station with some interesting automotive memorabilia. Nice well lit dining room, and a pretty large patio. Not many parking spaces, but there is plenty of street parking in the area.
Jul 20, 2019
We sat at the bar and had the thinner crust pizza with pepperoni. The pizza was fantastic and the service was great. The other patrons at the bar were friendly and welcoming. They had a really nice vibe on a Friday night. I am already planning my next visit.
Nov 28, 2019
Some of the best pizza in all of Durham.
Great cocktails and a place to get together with friends. Gotta appreciate they always gave a gin drink on the list.
And they've got Gansett :)
Jan 6, 2020
This was an excellent slice. It's a weird place. Like a really cool bar that forgot there was a great pizza place in the back of it. The decor is the current Durham rehab chic but well done and cozy. I bet the place is amazing in the summer but the ambiance suits an early winter night just as well.
But who cares. It's pizza. Really good pizza. Cocktails, beers on tap and damn good pizza. Salads, sandwiches. I think I saw some soup? You'll love it.
Jan 17, 2020
Durham has a great pizzeria scene and this one is giving a tough competition to others. They have unique signature pizzas and gluten free vegan options, which was an added benefit.
We had the gluten free eggplant parmesan and absolutely loved it. The eggplant was beautifully crisp. We also ordered the pesto with broccoli rabe and pickled red pepper, with gluten free and vegan cheese. The taste was good but slightly spicy. Our friends had also ordered the truffle mushroom, which tasted great.
The prices I felt was quite steep. Other than that, we had a great time and the staff were very friendly as well.
Jan 12, 2020
Great hangout place and awesome location. Yummy food and great drinks. Easy vibe and the staff was efficient and pleasant. Love the indoor and outdoor seating.
Jan 20, 2020
Great food and a friendly staff. The pizza is great - nice, crispy crust. We love going here for lunch as its pretty close to the office and they are always quick to serve. Give 'em a try - it's worth it!
Mar 2, 2020
The menu is very unique. Our party got a variety of items and everything was scrumptious. Casual vibe in the place...comfortable wearing whatever. Decent music too.
Mar 1, 2020
Fantastic casual spot, especially in nice weather. I tried 3 of the specialty pizzas - all fantastic, but my favorite part my meals by far was the Fattoush salad on the specials menu. So good!
Jul 20, 2019
The garage theme was nice with bright signs, concrete floors and large garage doors. The menu only offers about 5-6 pizzas. There is, however an option to build your own. A search for pizza places gives this 1 $...It is not...it is $$ and that starts at a medium size pizza. The cheese has a nice rich taste..but there are no sun dried tomatoes...just cherry tomatoes. The veggie toppings are very fresh and crisp; but the back/end of crust comes out dark and tough. Didn't drink, but there is a bar with a variety of beer and some wine. Very laid back spot...shorts, flip flops and sundresses should suffice. Some sort of construction going on out front; but decent amount of parking in a lot to the right of the building within walking distance.
Jun 3, 2020
Amazing pizza and awesome staff/owners. TBH I like coming here more than Pizzeria Toro because the quality of the pizza is comparable and the atmosphere is much more laid back. I love sitting at the bar- all the bartenders are awesome!! Love this place so much!