Loading your recommendations…

Hamilton Hill Jewelry

4.9

905 W Main St
Durham, NC 27701
Phone: (919) 683-1474
Visit Website

Located in Brightleaf Square, Hamilton Hill is the perfect shop for custom-made jewelry and staple pieces that will last for years to come. Work one-on-one with their in-store goldsmith to create the jewelry you have been dreaming of. Make sure to give Billie, the shop pup, a pet when you visit.


Google Reviews

Photo of Bianca Lupan Bianca Lupan
Aug 23, 2024 5

I have been to Hamilton Hill Jewelry several times for jewelry repairs and they have done an excellent job each time. In the past I tried a couple other jewelry repair stores but the necklaces ended up breaking again in the same places -- I have never had this problem with Hamilton Hill repairs. I've had several repaired necklaces for a few years now and they are still looking great. Their jewelry selection is also beautiful and everyone I have interacted with has been very nice.

Photo of Alexandra Bennion Alexandra Bennion
Aug 22, 2024 5

I cannot recommend Hamilton Hill enough for all of your jewelry needs! My fiancé and I initially came in to have my engagement ring re-sized - Hamilton Hill did a beautiful job. Even though the engagement ring was purchased from another jeweler, they were more than happy to help us at an amazing price. We ended up falling in love with a wedding band at the store, and are proud Hamilton Hill customers. We worked with Lilla for both the resizing and wedding band purchasing process and she is absolutely fantastic. My fiancé and I did not know much about the different metal options for bands, and Lilla kindly walked us through all of our options. She took the time to really get to know us, and picked out the perfect wedding band for us on the first try. I have never been to a jeweler where everyone is as kind and helpful as Hamilton Hill. We will be Hamilton Hill customers for life! Thank you so much.

Photo of Carolyn Yanavich Carolyn Yanavich
Aug 8, 2024 5

I’ve always been a fan of Antonio Bernardo jewelry and it’s hard to find in the US and Sarah and Hamilton Hill have the best selection of any shop I’ve seen! I loved a piece that ended up being sold before I could purchase it and Sarah and her team were so helpful in coordinating with the designer in Brazil to be able to get it for me as a special order. Although it took a while to arrive from Brazil, they were so great in keeping me posted on the status and made sure that it arrived just in time for me to take on vacation! If you are looking for phenomenal customer service, Hamilton Hill hits the mark on all accounts! Thank you again!

Photo of Stephen McKinney Stephen McKinney
Jul 26, 2024 5

10/10 experience working with Kai and the rest of the team at Hamilton Hill! Kai helped me pick out my wife’s engagement ring as well as our wedding bands. Additionally, when I recently lost my wedding band, she helped us replace the ring in an stress-free and timely manner. Kai is patient, kind, and the entire team at HH is extremely knowledgeable. Highly recommend :)

Photo of Lindsey Phillips Lindsey Phillips
Apr 13, 2024 5

My partner and I are so pleased with our experience shopping for and buying our wedding rings at Hamilton Hill. Sarah is so knowledgeable and helped us pick out the perfect rings. We visited multiple times to consider options and be re-sized, and she and the staff were so patient and helpful throughout. She and the staff were easy to communicate with through text message and kept me updated on the progress of my Niessing ring coming from Germany. Thank you for a lovely experience!

Photo of Monique Monique
Dec 28, 2023 5

This is the first stop my fiancée and I made to look at engagement rings. We were both so overwhelmed with the process until we stepped into the door at Hamilton Hill. Sarah helped us pick out the most perfect rings that matched each other perfectly. The entire team here is absolutely amazing. Communication is spectacular and we couldn’t have made a better decision than deciding to stop here first. We will always recommend Hamilton Hill time and time again when it comes to engagement rings or any nice jewelry pieces.

Photo of Robert Thompson Robert Thompson
Dec 17, 2023 5

I took my wife to do some "looking around" before Christmas. We had an absolutely wonderful time at Hamilton Hill. Sara Hill took us through their beautiful collection and my wife fell in love with a few pieces. As a husband, I appreciate those who treat my wife with such kindness as I saw today. We arrived happy and left happy. I am excited to return, I see many treats for my wife and maybe one for myself in the future.

Photo of Steve De Santis Steve De Santis
Dec 9, 2023 4

Atmosphere is great. Sarah and her staff always make you feel welcome, listen to you and are very knowledgeable. Lots of great things you won't see anywhere else. Did not have the best experience with their goldsmith when having something reset. Not enough to keep me from going back for purchases.

Photo of Kimberly Harry Kimberly Harry
Nov 30, 2023 5

I've been married for over 35 years and it was time to reset my diamond. Being a farmer, I had to stop wearing my traditionally-set diamond after bending a prong while working with livestock and machinery. Kai Hill, an amazing goldsmith, listened to my concerns and understood my desire to wear my ring rather than keep it in a drawer. She designed an amazing ring and we added a small sapphire to the wedding band. So beautiful!! Kai told me that I should be able to wear my rings on the farm and I admit I was skeptical, but I have been wearing them 24/7 for weeks now and hardly notice they're there. I have never caught my diamond on anything while working and the setting is easy to clean. Kai and the staff at Hamilton Hill Jewelry are incredible and I highly recommend them!